Why Comcast is not a great ISP.
August 24th, 2007 by Jake
A little contradictory considering my last entry, I know. But I just recently found out that Comcast, using a special network application, is blocking BitTorrent seeding. Using specific software known as Sandvine, it allows Comcast to allow upload traffic, but only when a download is in progress. As soon as you start seeding, this application tags all BitTorrent traffic with the “RST” flag (read more about the RST flag at Wikipedia).
I’ve recieved mixed reports about this. Some of my fellow Comcast subscribers say they have been affected by this new software, others closer in proximity to my location have reported that this is not the case (yet).
Either way, this is the beginning of the end for the internet, as far as I can tell. First one protocol, then another, then it’s $5/mo extra to access YouTube, then it’s $1/mo/service you want to use on their lines (HTTP, FTP, SSH, etc). Okay, maybe it won’t be that bad, at least not for awhile. But it could be the future of the internet for your kids… and guess who’s gonna pay that bill? :)
Kevin Walter says:
August 24th, 2007 at 8:03 pm
I absolutely believe it will be that bad, and sooner than you think. Welcome to a world where even a libertarian like me advocates for net neutrality.
Steel Froggy says:
September 1st, 2007 at 4:22 pm
ha…
You know, that REALLY explains why lately there have been a LOT less seeders…. hmmm…
Damn, I use comcast.
Then again, I’m not really the one upset. I don’t use P2P all that often, but I kinda feel bad for the people who AREN’T using comcast…
Now they’re seeding, the comcast users are downloading from them and using their bandwith, then they don’t can’t even seed it themselves.
Steel Froggy says:
September 1st, 2007 at 4:23 pm
oops, don’t was supposed to be crossed out, sorry. :P
(In the last sentence)